diff --git a/components/signup.php b/components/signup.php
index b1644087fe59201a4d71dde0bc05c9264c72601b..70932364a1037774dddf6176da05239b543e9a8c 100644
--- a/components/signup.php
+++ b/components/signup.php
@@ -322,8 +322,9 @@ if(isset($_REQUEST['signupid'])&&isset($_REQUEST['signuppw'])){
 					    }
 				    }
 			    }
-	
-                            if ($row['type']!=2){	
+
+				//Wrong logic, only students have student email addresses ~imranh
+                            if ($row['type']==1){
 			            $addtolist ="".$fields['email']."\n".$fields['studentid']."@swan.ac.uk";
                             }else{
 				    $addtolist="".$fields['email']."\n"; //Societies don't have student email addresses